Marnie McPhail Star Slade Noah Lamanna Richard Jutras Ben Platt Molly Gordon Noah Galvin Jimmy Tatro Caroline Aaron Nathan Lee Graham Owen Thiele Amy Sedaris Patti Harrison Bailee Bonick Kyndra Sanchez Donovan Colan Vivienne Sachs Alan Kim Alexander Bello Jennifer Lawrence Andrew Barth Feldman Laura Benanti Matthew Broderick Natalie Morales Scott MacArthur Ebon Moss-Bachrach Kyle Mooney Hasan Minhaj Jordan Mendoza Amalia Yoo Alysia Joy Powell Quincy Dunn-Baker Matthew Noszka Zahn McClarnon Paul Dano Shailene Woodley Pete Davidson Myha'la Herrold Talia Ryder Anthony Ramos Nick Offerman Sebastian Stan